YourRoots by Genomelink
banner

Sign up to explore more

Create a free account to navigate family trees, view ancestors, and discover connections.

Carter McDonald 1800–1872 – Genealogical Records

Birth Date: abt 1800

Birth Location: Virginia

Death Date: 1872

Death Location: Columbia City, Whitley County, Indiana, United States of America

Father: John McDonald

Mother: Eleanor Piatt

Spouse(s): Mary Carder

Children(s): Sarah McDonald, Andrew McDonald, Eliza McDonald, Samuel McDonald, Silas McDonald, Mary McDonald, James McDonald, William McDonald, Isaiah Donald, Melzar McDonald, Joseph McDonald, Elizabeth McDonald, Sarah McDonald, David McDonald, Malachi McDonald, Samuel McDonald, Andrew McDonald, William McDonald, David McDonald

The story of Carter McDonald began in 1800 in Virginia. In 1840, Carter McDonald resided in Salt Creek, Wayne, Ohio, USA. Carter McDonald married Mary Elizabeth Carder, Robertson Benham, and had children including Andrew Jackson Mcdonald, Andrew Mcdonald, David Mcdonald, Eliza H Mcdonald, Elizabeth H Mcdonald, Isaiah R Mc Donald, James Mcdonald, Joseph G Mcdonald, Malachi Mcdonald, Mary Mcdonald, Melger Mc Donald, Melzar M Mcdonald, Samuel B Mcdonald, Samuel Mcdonald, Sarah Jane Mcdonald, Silas Mcdonald, William Mcdonald. Carter McDonald passed away in 1872 in Columbia City, Whitley County, Indiana, United States of America.

Find more search results for Carter McDonald
CM

Reliability Score

This score reflects the reliability of the source family tree. A high rating indicates a trustworthy source with strong data consistency.

Reliability Score:
A
Criteria:
  • A 3 criteria (Strong)
  • B 2 criteria (Medium)
  • C 1 criteria (Basic)
  • N/A 0 criteria (Insufficient)

This tree's reliability score:

  • Record available
  • Descendant's record available
  • Star tree owner

Biography

  • The story of Carter McDonald began in 1800 in Virginia.
  • In 1840, Carter McDonald resided in Salt Creek, Wayne, Ohio, USA.
  • Carter McDonald married Mary Elizabeth Carder, Robertson Benham, and had children including Andrew Jackson Mcdonald, Andrew Mcdonald, David Mcdonald, Eliza H Mcdonald, Elizabeth H Mcdonald, Isaiah R Mc Donald, James Mcdonald, Joseph G Mcdonald, Malachi Mcdonald, Mary Mcdonald, Melger Mc Donald, Melzar M Mcdonald, Samuel B Mcdonald, Samuel Mcdonald, Sarah Jane Mcdonald, Silas Mcdonald, William Mcdonald.
  • Carter McDonald passed away in 1872 in Columbia City, Whitley County, Indiana, United States of America.

Immediate Family

Parents

John McDonald
1775–1822
Birth Location: Northumberland, PA, USA
JM
Eleanor Piatt
1786–1866
Birth Location: Potter, Northumberland, Pennsylvania, United States
EP

Spouses(s)

Mary Carder
1806–1883
Birth Location: Virginia
MC

Children(s)

Sarah McDonald
1843–1885
Birth Location: Ohio
SM
Andrew McDonald
1842–
Birth Location: Indiana
AM
Eliza McDonald
1849–1884
Birth Location: Indiana
EM
Samuel McDonald
1830–
Birth Location: Virginia
SM
Silas McDonald
1835–1901
Birth Location: Virginia
SM
Mary McDonald
1836–1906
Birth Location: Virginia
MM
James McDonald
1839–1864
Birth Location: O
JM
William McDonald
1841–1909
Birth Location: O
WM
Isaiah Donald
1826–1907
Birth Location: Virginia
ID
Melzar McDonald
1822–1904
Birth Location: –
MM
Joseph McDonald
1845–
Birth Location: –
JM
Elizabeth McDonald
1849–1884
Birth Location: Indiana
EM
Sarah McDonald
1843–1906
Birth Location: Ohio
SM
David McDonald
1833–1874
Birth Location: Culpeper, Culpeper, Virginia, United States
DM
Malachi McDonald
1834–1892
Birth Location: Virginia, United States
MM
Samuel McDonald
1829–1903
Birth Location: Virginia, USA
SM
Andrew McDonald
1845–
Birth Location: Indiana
AM
William McDonald
1841–1909
Birth Location: Ohio
WM
David McDonald
1837–1874
Birth Location: Culpepper, Rappahannock, Virginia, United States
DM

Carter McDonald's Ancestors

Self
Carter McDonald
1800–1872
Birth Place: Virginia
Parents
John McDonald
1775–1822
Northumberland, PA, USA
Eleanor Piatt
1786–1866
Potter, Northumberland, Pennsylvania, United States
Grandparents
Abraham ((Capt. "Quartermaster")) Piatt
1741–1791
Six Mile Run, Middlesex, New Jersey, USA
Annabelle (Colla) Andrew
1748–1822
Six Mile Run, Middlesex, New Jersey, USA
Great-Grandparents
John Piatt
1712–1760
Frances VanVliet
1713–1776
James Andrews
1714–1755
Catherine Andrews
1723–1791
2nd-Great-Grandparents

Carter McDonald's Descendants

1.
CM
Carter McDonald (abt 1800–1872) m. Mary (Elizabeth) Carder (abt 1806–1883)
  1. 1. Sarah (Jane) McDonald 1843–1885 m. Alfred (B) Payton 1838–1906
    1. 1. Cyrus (Edson) Payton 1863–1917 m. Mary (Elizabeth) Darby 1865–1943 m. Clara (Belle) Benedict 1870–
      1. 1. Grace (L.) Payton 1886–1953 m. Ott (Pindel) Prickett 1885–1956
        1. 1. Benjamin (G) Prickett 1923–1967 m. Mary (K) Prickett 1924–2018
        2. 2. John (Lawrence) Prickett 1912–1998
        3. 3. Mary (Lois) Prickett 1914–2012
        4. 4. Paul (Carver) Prickett 1916–2009
        5. 5. Esther (J) Pricket 1919–2023
        6. 6. Joseph (Warren) Prickett 1920–1999
        7. 7. Elizabeth (Jane) Prickett 1907–2010
        8. 8. Elizabeth Prickett 1908–
        9. 9. James (Payton) Prickett 1909–
        10. 10. Joseph (Warren) Prickett 1920–1999
      2. 2. Russell (Eugene) Payton 1903–
      3. 3. Thomas (C) Payton 1891–
      4. 4. Russel Payton 1904–
      5. 5. Eugene Payton 1910–
      6. 6. Russell (Eugene) Payton 1903–
      7. 7. Hazel Payton 1895–
      8. 8. Nellie (E) Payton 1910–
    2. 2. A. (Agnes) Paton 1865–
    3. 3. Amanda (Paton) mcsweeney 1869–
    4. 4. Susana Paton 1873–
    5. 5. Charles Paton 1875–
    6. 6. A. (Agnes) Paton 1865–1925
    7. 7. Amanda Paton 1870–
    8. 8. Susana Paton 1873–
    9. 9. Charles Paton 1875–1959
  2. 2. Andrew McDonald 1842–
  3. 3. Eliza (H) McDonald 1849–1884
  4. 4. Samuel McDonald 1830–
  5. 5. Silas McDonald 1835–1901
  6. 6. Mary McDonald 1836–1906
  7. 7. James McDonald 1839–1864
  8. 8. William McDonald 1841–1909
  9. 9. Isaiah (R. Mc) Donald 1826–1907
  10. 10. Melzar (M.) McDonald 1822–1904
  11. 11. Joseph (G) McDonald 1845–
  12. 12. Elizabeth (h) McDonald 1849–1884
  13. 13. Sarah (Jane) McDonald 1843–1906
  14. 14. David McDonald 1833–1874
  15. 15. Malachi McDonald 1834–1892
  16. 16. Samuel (B) McDonald 1829–1903
  17. 17. Andrew (Jackson) McDonald 1845–
  18. 18. William McDonald 1841–1909
  19. 19. David McDonald 1837–1874

Carter McDonald's Timeline

9 Records

1800
abt 1800
Birth of Carter McDonald in Virginia
Virginia
1822
1822
Age 22
Carter McDonald was married in Culpepper, Rappahannock, Virginia, United States
Culpepper, Rappahannock, Virginia, United States
1840
1840
Age 40
Carter McDonald resided here in Salt Creek, Wayne, Ohio, USA
Salt Creek, Wayne, Ohio, USA
1850
1850
Age 50
Carter McDonald resided here in Whitley, Indiana, USA
Whitley, Indiana, USA
1860
1860
Age 60
Carter McDonald resided here in Troy, Whitley, Indiana, USA
Troy, Whitley, Indiana, USA
1870
1870
Age 70
Carter McDonald resided here in Troy, Larwill, Whitley, Indiana, USA
Troy, Larwill, Whitley, Indiana, USA
1872
Abt 1872
Age 72
Carter McDonald resided here in Indiana, Whitley
Indiana, Whitley
1872
1872
Age 72
Death of Carter McDonald in Indiana, USA
Indiana, USA
1872
28 Jun 1872
Age 72
Carter McDonald - Probate in Whitley, Indiana, USA
Whitley, Indiana, USA

Sources

    Genealogy Event 1
    Event Type: Birth
    Event Date: abt 1800
    Event Place: Virginia
    Record Source:
    [1] Ohio, Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Center Obituary Index, Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Center; Spiegel Grove, Fremont, Ohio; Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Center Ohio Obituary Index, 1830s to 2011
    [2] 1870 United States Federal Census, Year: 1870; Census Place: Troy, Whitley, Indiana; Roll: M593_373; Page: 472A
    [3] 1860 United States Federal Census, The National Archives in Washington D.C.; Record Group: Records of the Bureau of the Census; Record Group Number: 29; Series Number: M653; Residence Date: 1860; Home in 1860: Troy, Whitley, Indiana; Roll: M653_307; Page: 783; Family History Library Film: 8
    [4] 1850 United States Federal Census, The National Archives in Washington, DC; Record Group: Records of the Bureau of the Census; Record Group Number: 29; Series Number: M432; Residence Date: 1850; Home in 1850: Whitley, Indiana; Roll: 181; Page: 471b
    [5] U.S., Find a Grave® Index, 1600s-Current
    [6] Geneanet Community Trees Index

    Genealogy Event 2
    Event Type: Marriage
    Event Date: 1822
    Event Place: Culpepper, Rappahannock, Virginia, United States

    Genealogy Event 3
    Event Type: Residence
    Event Date: 1840
    Event Place: Salt Creek, Wayne, Ohio, USA
    Record Source: 1840 United States Federal Census, Year: 1840; Census Place: Salt Creek, Wayne, Ohio; Roll: 432; Page: 181; Family History Library Film: 0020179

    Genealogy Event 4
    Event Type: Residence
    Event Date: 1850
    Event Place: Whitley, Indiana, USA
    Record Source: 1850 United States Federal Census, The National Archives in Washington, DC; Record Group: Records of the Bureau of the Census; Record Group Number: 29; Series Number: M432; Residence Date: 1850; Home in 1850: Whitley, Indiana; Roll: 181; Page: 471b

    Genealogy Event 5
    Event Type: Residence
    Event Date: 1860
    Event Place: Troy, Whitley, Indiana, USA
    Record Source: 1860 United States Federal Census, The National Archives in Washington D.C.; Record Group: Records of the Bureau of the Census; Record Group Number: 29; Series Number: M653; Residence Date: 1860; Home in 1860: Troy, Whitley, Indiana; Roll: M653_307; Page: 783; Family History Library Film: 8

    Genealogy Event 6
    Event Type: Residence
    Event Date: 1870
    Event Place: Troy, Larwill, Whitley, Indiana, USA
    Record Source: 1870 United States Federal Census, Year: 1870; Census Place: Troy, Whitley, Indiana; Roll: M593_373; Page: 472A

    Genealogy Event 7
    Event Type: Residence
    Event Date: Abt 1872
    Event Place: Indiana, Whitley
    Record Source: Indiana, Wills and Probate Records, Will Record, 1839-1928; Author: Indiana. Circuit Court (Whitley County)

    Genealogy Event 8
    Event Type: Death
    Event Date: 1872
    Event Place: Indiana, USA
    Record Source:
    [1] Ohio, Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Center Obituary Index, Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Center; Spiegel Grove, Fremont, Ohio; Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Center Ohio Obituary Index, 1830s to 2011
    [2] Indiana, Wills and Probate Records, Will Record, 1839-1928; Author: Indiana. Circuit Court (Whitley County)
    [3] U.S., Find a Grave® Index, 1600s-Current
    [4] Geneanet Community Trees Index

    Genealogy Event 9
    Event Type: Burial
    Event Place: Columbia City, Whitley County, Indiana, United States of America
    Record Source: U.S., Find a Grave® Index, 1600s-Current

    Genealogy Event 10
    Event Type: Probate
    Event Date: 28 Jun 1872
    Event Place: Whitley, Indiana, USA
    Record Source: Indiana, Wills and Probate Records, Will Record, 1839-1928; Author: Indiana. Circuit Court (Whitley County)
Find more search results for Carter McDonald

About YourRoots

Family Tree Map

Explore your family tree geographically

Import your GEDCOM file to transform your family tree into an interactive global map. See your roots laid out visually and understand your true geographic heritage.

Powerful tools like "Trace Back To Me" instantly map your family's migration paths from a chosen ancestor all the way back to you.

LEARN MORE
AI Genealogy Research

Discover ancestors beyond "end-of-line" automatically

Import your family tree and let AI expand it for you. AI Ancestor Finder scans "end-of-line" ancestors to uncover their parents across hundreds of family lines at once. AI Deep Research analyzes selected ancestors and family clusters, suggesting relevant records and next steps.

Turn on Auto Research Mode to get new discoveries daily or weekly, so your tree keeps growing even while you're away.

LEARN MORE
DNA Match

Find more DNA matches across all DNA tests

Combine your DNA data with your family tree to unlock the full power of YourRoots DNA Match. Connect with relatives across major testing services — Ancestry, 23andMe, MyHeritage, and more.

View your matches' maps and trees to identify shared ancestors, and soon you'll be able to add them directly to your own tree and map.

LEARN MORE
Ancestry Reports

Ancestry DNA analysis that goes deeper than others

Unlock exclusive reports that reveal your deeper origins.

  • Deep Ancestry Report — Analyze 130+ ethnicities, sub-regions, and 1,800+ communities in one detailed view.
  • Global & Native American Reports — Developed with Stanford researchers to uncover hidden ancestries across all 22 chromosomes.
  • Ancient DNA Series — Compare your DNA with 1,000+ ancient genomes from Viking, Celtic, and early American civilizations.
LEARN MORE