YourRoots Logo
Sign up free
banner

Sign up to explore more

Create a free account to navigate family trees, view ancestors, and discover connections.

Sign up free

Sarah Catherine Underhill 1867 – 1945 – Genealogical Records

Birth Date: Nov 1867

Birth Location: Indiana

Death Date: 20 Nov 1945

Death Location: Rural, Orange, Indiana, USA

Father: John Underhill

Mother: Sarah Sigler

Spouse(s): Joel McMahel

Children(s): Noah McMahel

The story of Sarah Catherine Underhill began in 1867 in Indiana. Sarah Catherine Underhill married Joel McMahel, and had children including Noah McMahel. Sarah Catherine Underhill passed away in 1945 in Rural, Orange, Indiana, USA.

Find more search results for Sarah Underhill
SU

Reliability Score

This score reflects the reliability of the source family tree. A high rating indicates a trustworthy source with strong data consistency.

Reliability Score:
C
Criteria:
  • A 3 criteria (Strong)
  • B 2 criteria (Medium)
  • C 1 criteria (Basic)
  • N/A 0 criteria (Insufficient)

This tree's reliability score:

  • Record available
  • Descendant's record available
  • Star tree owner

Biography

  • The story of Sarah Catherine Underhill began in 1867 in Indiana.
  • Sarah Catherine Underhill married Joel McMahel, and had children including Noah McMahel.
  • Sarah Catherine Underhill passed away in 1945 in Rural, Orange, Indiana, USA.

Immediate Family

Parents

John Underhill
1826 – 1911
Birth Location: Crawford County, Indiana, United States of America
JU
Sarah Sigler
1829 – 1906
Birth Location: Floyd County, Indiana, United States of America
SS

Spouses(s)

Joel McMahel
1867 – 1946
Birth Location: Indiana, United States of America
JM

Children(s)

Noah McMahel
1893 – 1981
Birth Location: Crawford County, Indiana, United States of America
NM

Sarah Underhill's Ancestors

Self
Sarah Underhill
1867 – 1945
Birth Place: Indiana
Parents
John Underhill
1826 – 1911
Crawford County, Indiana, United States of America
Sarah (Saville) Sigler
1829 – 1906
Floyd County, Indiana, United States of America
Grandparents
William Underhill
1796 – 1845
Nelson Co KY
Susannah (Elizabeth) Sturgeon
1797 – 1892
Nelson, Kentucky, USA
Isaac (W) Sigler
1805 – 1867
Tennessee, United States of America
Martha (Jane) Davis
1809 – 1859
Pennsylvania, United States
Great-Grandparents
James Underhill
1765 – 1845
Mary Sturgeon
1775 – 1840
Elizabeth Miller
1794 – 1860
2nd-Great-Grandparents
William Underhill*
1731 – 1815

Sarah Underhill's Descendants

1.
SU
Sarah (Catherine) Underhill (Nov 1867 – 20 Nov 1945) m. Joel McMahel (24 September 1867 – 28 March 1946)
  1. 1. Noah McMahel (12 December 1893 – 20 March 1981) m. Elsie (Dale) Bennett
    1. 1. Duane (Ronald) McMahel (07/19/1935 – 03-2023-04) m. Carolyn (J) McMahel (Dec 1946 – 20-2024-08)
      1. 1. Kimberly McMahel (21-1977-09 – ) m. Daniel Reed (04/14/1974 – ) m. Bradley Harold
        1. 1. Cody Reed (14 Aug 2002 – )
        2. 2. Elijah Alexandre (02-1996-08 – )

Sarah Underhill's Timeline

2 Records

1867
Nov 1867
Birth of Sarah Catherine Underhill in Indiana
Indiana
1945
20 Nov 1945
Age 78
Death of Sarah Catherine Underhill in Rural, Orange, Indiana, USA
Rural, Orange, Indiana, USA

Sources

    Genealogy Event 1
    Event Type: Birth
    Event Date: Nov 1867
    Event Place: Indiana

    Genealogy Event 2
    Event Type: Death
    Event Date: 20 Nov 1945
    Event Place: Rural, Orange, Indiana, USA
Find more search results for Sarah Underhill

About YourRoots

Family Tree Map

Explore your family tree geographically

Import your GEDCOM file to transform your family tree into an interactive global map. See your roots laid out visually and understand your true geographic heritage.

Powerful tools like “Trace Back To Me” instantly map your family’s migration paths from a chosen ancestor all the way back to you.

LEARN MORE
AI Genealogy Research

Discover ancestors beyond “end-of-line” automatically

Import your family tree and let AI expand it for you. AI Ancestor Finder scans “end-of-line” ancestors to uncover their parents across hundreds of family lines at once. AI Deep Research analyzes selected ancestors and family clusters, suggesting relevant records and next steps.

Turn on Auto Research Mode to get new discoveries daily or weekly, so your tree keeps growing even while you’re away.

LEARN MORE
DNA Match

Find more DNA matches across all DNA tests

Combine your DNA data with your family tree to unlock the full power of YourRoots DNA Match. Connect with relatives across major testing services — Ancestry, 23andMe, MyHeritage, and more.

View your matches’ maps and trees to identify shared ancestors, and soon you’ll be able to add them directly to your own tree and map.

LEARN MORE
Ancestry Reports

Ancestry DNA analysis that goes deeper than others

Unlock exclusive reports that reveal your deeper origins.

  • Deep Ancestry Report — Analyze 130+ ethnicities, sub-regions, and 1,800+ communities in one detailed view.
  • Global & Native American Reports — Developed with Stanford researchers to uncover hidden ancestries across all 22 chromosomes.
  • Ancient DNA Series — Compare your DNA with 1,000+ ancient genomes from Viking, Celtic, and early American civilizations.
LEARN MORE